Re-framing the geography dissertation: A consideration of alternative, innovative and creative approaches

Hill, J. and Kneale, P. and Nicholson, D. and Waddington, S. and Ray, W. (2011) Re-framing the geography dissertation: A consideration of alternative, innovative and creative approaches. Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 35 (3). pp. 331-349. ISSN 03098265 (ISSN)

Full text not available from this resource.
Official URL:


This paper reviews the opportunities and challenges for re-framing the purpose, process, product and assessment of final-year geography dissertations. It argues that the academic centralities of critical thinking, analysis, evaluation, effective communication and independence must be retained, but that the traditional format limits creativity and innovation. Re-imagining capstone projects has implications for students, faculty, departments and institutions, but greater diversity could enhance its relevance to students and employers, better aligning the student experience with the academic interests and future career demands of the 21st century graduate. © 2011 Taylor & Francis.

Item Type: Article
Additional Information: Cited By :1; Export Date: 23 February 2015; Correspondence Address: Kneale, P.; Higher Education Subject Centre for Geography, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Plymouth, Buckland House, Drake Circus, Plymouth PL4 8AA, United Kingdom; email:; References: Aller, B.M., Lyth, D.M., Mallak, L.A., Capstone project team formation: Mingling increases performance and motivation (2008) Decision Sciences Journal of Innovation Education, 6, pp. 503-507; Amin, A., Roberts, J., Knowing in action: Beyond communities of practice (2008) Research Policy, 37, pp. 353-369; Arnot, M., McIntyre, D., Peddar, D., Reay, D., (2004) Consultation in the Classroom: Developing Dialogue About Teaching and Learning, , Cambridge: Pearson; Askins, K., In and beyond the classroom: Research ethics and participatory pedagogies (2008) Area, 40, pp. 500-509; Balla, J., Boyle, P., Assessment of student performance: A framework for improving practice (1994) Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 19, pp. 17-28; Baxter, M.M., (1999) Creating Contexts for Learning and Self-authorship: Constructive Developmental Pedagogy; Baxter, M.M., Educating for self-authorship: Learning partnerships to achieve complex outcomes (2009) The University and Its Disciplines: Teaching and Learning Within and Beyond Disciplinary Boundaries, pp. 143-156. , in: C. Kreber (Ed.), Oxford: Routledge; Bednarz, S., Chalkley, B., Fletcher, S., Hay, I., Le Heron, E., Mohan, A., Trafford, J., Community engagement for student learning in geography (2008) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 32, pp. 87-100; Boud, D., Cohen, R., Sampson, J., Peer learning and assessment (1999) Assessment in Higher Education, 24, pp. 413-426; (1998) Reinventing Undergraduate Education: A Blueprint for America's Research Universities, , Boyer Commission on Educating Undergraduates in the Research University, (Stony Brook, NY: State University of New York at Stony Brook); Brackin, M.P., Gibson, J.D., Capstone Design Projects with Industry: Emphasizing Teaming and Management Tools (2005) ASEE Annual Conference and Exposition, Conference Proceedings, pp. 1477-1484; Brew, A., Teaching and research: New relationships and their implications for inquiry-based teaching and learning in higher education (2003) Higher Education Research and Development, 22, pp. 3-18; Brew, A., (2006) Research and Teaching Beyond the Divide, , London: Palgrave MacMillan; Bruhn, R., Camp, J., Capstone course creates useful business products and corporate-ready students (2004) SIGCSE Bulletin (Association for Computing Machinery, Special Interest Group on Computer Science Education), 36, pp. 87-92; Chalkley, B., Gibson, K., Enterprise education in geography: The case of the Plymouth dragons (2009) Planet, 21, pp. 43-46; Chalkley, B., Harwood, J., (1998) Transferable Skills and Work-based Learning in Geography, , Cheltenham: Geography Discipline Network; Chang, H., Turning an undergraduate class into a professional research community (2005) Teaching in Higher Education, 10, pp. 387-394; Charlesworth, S.M., Foster, I.D.L., Water and environmental systems': Achieving student-centred learning objectives with an undergraduate journal (1996) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 20, pp. 45-54; Dorsey, B., Linking theories of service-learning and undergraduate geography education (2001) Journal of Geography, 100, pp. 124-132; Dougherty, J., Parfitt, K., Framework for teaching engineering capstone design courses with emphasis on application of Internet-based technologies (2009) Journal of Architectural Engineering, 15, pp. 4-9; Dutson, A.J., Todd, R.H., Magleby, S.P., Sorenson, C.D., A review of literature on teaching engineering design through project-oriented capstone courses (1997) Journal of Engineering Education, 86, pp. 17-28; Elliott, D., Meisel, J., Richards, W., The senior project: Using the literature of distinguished economists (1998) Journal of Economic Education, 29, pp. 312-320; Fielding, M., Radical collegiality: Affirming teaching as an inclusive professional practice (1999) Australian Educational Researcher, 26, pp. 1-34; Fielding, M., Students as radical agents of change (2001) Journal of Educational Change, 2, pp. 123-141; Fielding, M., Transformative approaches to student voice: Theoretical underpinnings, recalcitrant realities (2004) British Educational Research Journal, 30, pp. 295-311; Fisher, C., (2007) Researching and Writing a Dissertation: A Guidebook for Business Students, , 2nd edn (Harlow: Pearson Education Ltd); Gemmel, A., 'Competitive' simulation in the teaching of applied geomorphology: An experiment (1995) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 19, pp. 29-39; Gemstone, (2010) The Gemstone Program at the University of Maryland, ,, Available at; Greenbank, P., Penketh, C., Student autonomy and reflections on researching and writing the undergraduate dissertation (2009) Journal of Further and Higher Education, 33, pp. 463-472; Hadfield, M., Hawe, K., 'Voice', young people and action research (2001) Educational Action Research, 9, pp. 85-99; Haigh, M.J., Internationalisation of the curriculum: Designing inclusive education for a small world (2002) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 26, pp. 49-66; Hand, L., Clewes, D., Marking the difference: An investigation of the criteria used for assessing undergraduate dissertations in a business school (2000) Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 25, pp. 5-21; Harrison, M.E., Whalley, W.B., Undertaking a dissertation from start to finish: The process and product (2008) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 32, pp. 401-418; Harvey, L., Moon, S., Geall, V., (1997) Graduates' Work: Organisational Change and Student Attributes, , (Birmingham: Centre for Research into Quality, University of Birmingham); Healey, M., (2010) Making Creative-hops Through Developing Creative Honours Projects: A Proposal, , Paper presented at the SRHE Student Experience Conference on Rethinking the Dissertation: The Role of Undergraduate Research in Higher Education. UCLan, Preston, 9 June; Healey, M., Jenkins, A., (2009) Developing Undergraduate Research and Inquiry, , York: HE Academy; Healey, M., Jenkins, A., Developing students as researchers (2009) Linking Research and Teaching and in Higher Education. Proceedings of the Newport Nexus Conference., pp. 7-11. , in: S. K. Haslett & H. Rolands, Centre for Excellence in Learning and Teaching, University of Wales, Wales. Special Publication No. 1; Hennemann, S., Liefner, I., Employability of German geography graduates: The mismatch between knowledge acquired and competences required (2010) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 34, pp. 215-230; Higgitt, D., Finding space for education for sustainable development in the enterprise economy (2006) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 30, pp. 251-262; Hodgson, D., May, S., Marks-Maran, D., Promoting the development of a supportive learning environment through action research from the 'middle out' (2008) Educational Action Research, 16, pp. 531-544; Hogg, J., Evaluation of the work-place cooperative project in geography degrees at the University of Leeds (1998) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 22, pp. 126-135; Hovorka, A.J., A capstone course of 'geographic ideas' (2009) Journal of Geography, 108, pp. 252-258; James, P., Progressive development of deep learning skills through undergraduate and postgraduate dissertations (1998) Educational Studies, 24, pp. 95-105; Jenkins, A., Designing a curriculum that values a research based approach to student learning in geography, earth and environmental sciences (GEES), Planet (2003) Special Edition, 5, pp. 2-5; Jenkins, A., Blackman, T., Lindsay, R., Paton-Saltzberg, R., Teaching and research: Student perspectives and policy implications (1998) Studies in Higher Education, 23, pp. 127-141; Jenkins, A., Breen, R., Lindsay, R., (2003) Re-shaping Higher Education: Linking Teaching and Research, , London: Routledge; Jenkins, A., Healey, M., Undergraduate research and international initiatives to link teaching and research (2010) Council on Undergraduate Research Quarterly, 30, pp. 36-42; Jenkins, A., Healey, M., Zetter, R., (2007) Linking Teaching and Research in Disciplines and Departments, , York: Higher Education Academy; Kostelnick, J.C., Rowley, R.J., McDermott, D., Bowen, C., Developing a GIS program at a tribal college (2009) Journal of Geography, 108, pp. 68-77; Latham, A., McCormack, D., Digital photography and web-based assignments in an urban field course: Snapshots from Berlin (2007) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 31, pp. 241-256; Lave, J., Wenger, E., (1991) Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation, , Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; Le Heron, R., Baker, R., McEwen, L., Co-learning: Re-linking research and teaching geography (2006) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 30 (1), pp. 77-87; Leidig, P.M., Ferguson, R., Leidig, J., The use of community-based non-profit organizations in information systems capstone projects (2006) Working Group Reports on ITiCSE on Innovation and Technology in Computer Science Education, pp. 148-152. , 11th Annual Joint Conference Integrating Technology into Computer Science Education, Universita' di Bologna, Bologna, Italy; Lloyd, D., Final year research projects in communicating science (2008) Student Research Projects: Guidance on Practice in the Biosciences, Teaching Bioscience Enhancing Learning Series, pp. 54-56. , in: M. Luck (Ed.), Leeds: The Higher Education Academy Centre for Bioscience; Lynch, K., Bednarz, B., Boxall, J., Chalmers, L., France, D., Kesby, J., E-learning for geography's teaching and learning spaces (2008) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 32, pp. 135-149; Lynch, K., Heinze, A., Scott, E., Information technology team projects in higher education: An international viewpoint (2007) Journal of Information Technology Education, 6, pp. 181-198; Mackeogh, K., Supervising undergraduate research using online and peer supervision (2006) Proceedings of the 7th International Virtual University Conference, ,, in: M. Huba (Ed.), 14-15 December 2006, Bratislava. TU Bratislava. Available at, accessed 1 July 2010; McCartney, C., (2006),, The University of Leeds Innocence Project, Available at, accessed 1 July 2010McEwen, E.E., Integrated capstone design experience (1994) Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice, 120, pp. 212-220; McGrann, R., Mackiewicz, G., Walsh, J., Williams, K., Griffin, J., Hobbs, Y., Crocker, M., Capstone design: Sculpture and structure (2005) ASEE Annual Conference and Exposition, Conference Proceedings, pp. 1485-1491. , Portland, Oregon; Maleki, R.A., Business and industry project-based capstone courses: A reflection on the performance of student teams (2009) Industry and Higher Education, 23, pp. 103-110; Nicholson, D.T., Embedding research in a field-based module through peer review and assessment for learning Journal of Geography in Higher Education, , (in press) DOI: 10.1080/03098265.2011.552104; Nicholson, D.T., Harrison, M.E., Whalley, W.B., Assessment criteria and standards of the Geography Dissertation in the UK (2010) Planet, 23, pp. 18-24; Oldfather, P., Songs 'come back to most of them': Students' experiences as researchers (1995) Theory Into Practice, 34, pp. 131-137; Pahl, O., Case study 8: The Vertical Project, Glasgow Caledonian University (2008) Quality Enhancement Themes: The First Year Experience, pp. 43-45. , in: F. M. Black & J. MacKenzie (Eds), Glasgow: Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education; Pathirage, C., Haigh, R., Amaratunga, D., Baldry, D., Enhancing the quality and consistency of undergraduate dissertation assessment (2007) Quality Assurance in Education, 15, pp. 271-286; Pepper, D., Webster, F., Jenkins, A., Benchmarking in geography: Some implications for assessing the dissertations in the undergraduate curriculum (2001) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 25, pp. 23-35; (2007) Geography, and Earth Sciences, Environmental Sciences and Environmental Studies Benchmark Statement, , QAA, Gloucester: Quality Assurance Agency; Rohleder, P., Swartz, L., Bozalek, V., Carolissen, R., Leibowitz, B., Community, self and identity: Participatory action research and the creation of a virtual community across two South African universities (2008) Teaching in Higher Education, 13, pp. 131-143; Rowles, C.J., Koch, D.C., Hundley, S.P., Hamilton, S.J., Towards a model for capstone experiences: Mountaintops, magnets and mandates (2004) Assessment Update: Progress, Trends and Practices in Higher Education, 16, pp. 1-2+13-15; Rowley, J., Slack, F., What is the future for undergraduate dissertations? (2004) Education and Training, 46, pp. 176-181; Saunders, M.N.K., Davis, S.M., The use of assessment criteria to ensure consistency of marking: Some implications for good practice (1998) Quality Assurance in Education, 6, pp. 162-171; Shah, A., Treby, E., Using a community based project to link teaching and research: The bourne stream partnership (2006) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 30, pp. 33-48; Simplicio, S.C., (2007) Educating the 21st Century Student, , Bloomington: AuthorHouse; Stefani, L.A., Tariq, V.N., Heylings, D.J.A., Butcher, A.C., A comparison of tutor and student conceptions of undergraduate research project work (1997) Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 22, pp. 271-288; Swanson, M.T., Bampton, M., Integrated digital mapping in geologic field research: An adventure-based approach to teaching new geospatial technologies in an REU Site Program (2009) Field Geology Education: Historical Perspectives and Modern Approaches: Geological Society of America Special Paper, 461, pp. 117-133. , in: S. J. Whitmeyer, D.W. Mogk, and E. J. Pyle (Eds.); Talley, T.J., Using a state-wide high school robotics competition as the basis for a capstone design experience in electrical engineering (1997) Proceedings-Frontiers in Education Conference, 2, pp. 775-777; Tatner, M., Tierney, A., Case study 6: Commercial projects for final year bioscience students (2008) Student Research Projects: Guidance on Practice in the Biosciences, pp. 51-53. , in: M. Luck (Ed.), Leeds: HEA Subject Centre for Bioscience; Terenzini, P.T., Pascarella, E.T., Studying college students in the 21st century: Meeting new challenges (1998) The Review of Higher Education, 21, pp. 151-165; Tilley, F., Parrish, B.D., Introduction to sustainability entrepreneurship research (2009) Greener Management International, 55, pp. 5-11; Troyer, R.J., Comments on the capstone course (1993) Teaching Sociology, 21, pp. 246-249; Turner, N., Wuetherick, B., Healey, M., International perspectives on student perceptions of research: The role of academic development in implementing research-based teaching and learning in higher education (2008) International Journal of Academic Development, 13, pp. 199-211; Waddington, S., Working with the community: Improving the learning experience for large classes (2001) Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 25, pp. 67-82; Wagner, R., Anderson, J.L., Cao, W., Gao, Y., Ikeda, T., Jacobs, R., Johanesen, K., Zhang, T., (2007) Geologic Wonders of Yosemite at Two Miles High: An Undergraduate, learner-centered, team research program, ,, the University of Southern California, American Geophysical Union, Fall Meeting 2007, abstract #ED21A-0082. Available at; Walkington, H., Geoverse: Piloting a national e-journal of undergraduate research in geography (2008) Planet, 20, pp. 41-46; Walkington, H., Jenkins, A., Embedding undergraduate research publication in the student learning experience: Ten suggested strategies (2008) Brookes E-journal of Learning and Teaching, 2 (3). ,, Available at; Wallen, M.R., Pandit, A.S., Encouraging undergraduate engineering students towards civic engagement (2009) European Journal of Engineering Education, 34, pp. 141-148; Webster, F., Pepper, D., Jenkins, A., Assessing the undergraduate dissertation (2000) Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 25, pp. 71-80; Wenger, E., (1998) Communities of Practice: Learning, Meaning and Identity, , Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; Whitmeyer, S.J., de Paor, D.G., Nicoletti, J., Rivera, M., Santangelo, B., Daniels, J., Cross-disciplinary Undergraduate Research: A Case Study In Digital Mapping (2008) American Geophysical Union, Fall Meeting, ,, western Ireland, 2008, abstract #ED52A-04. Available at; Willison, J., O'Regan, K., Commonly known, commonly not known, totally unknown: A framework for students becoming researchers (2007) Higher Education Research and Development, 26, pp. 393-409; Woolf, H., Assessment criteria: Reflections on current practices (2004) Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, 29, pp. 479-493; Zamorski, B., Research-led teaching and learning in higher education (2002) Teaching in Higher Education, 7, pp. 411-427
Uncontrolled Keywords: Assessment; Capstone project; Creativity; Dissertation; Innovation; geography education; research work; student
Depositing User: Colin Lowry
Last Modified: 27 Nov 2015 09:51

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year