Using interactive management to facilitate a student-centred conceptualisation of critical thinking: a case study

Dwyer, C. P. and Hogan, M. J. and Harney, O. M. and O’Reilly, J. (2014) Using interactive management to facilitate a student-centred conceptualisation of critical thinking: a case study. pp. 687-709. ISSN 10421629 (ISSN)

[img] Text
Dwyer et al 2014.pdf

Download (444kB)
Official URL:


Critical thinking (CT) is a metacognitive process, consisting of a number of sub-skills and dispositions, that, when used appropriately, increases the chances of producing a logical solution to a problem or a valid conclusion to an argument. CT has been identified as a fundamental learning objective of third-level education; however, students often report not being given the opportunity to adequately understand and cultivate CT skills. Though most CT interventions are designed based on academic or expert definitions of CT skills, students are rarely, if ever, asked to guide their instruction by describing their perspectives on what constitutes CT. The current case study investigated students’ conceptualisations of what constitutes good CT using a collective intelligence methodology, interactive management. Interactive management (IM) is a computer-assisted process that allows a group to build a structural model describing relations between elements in a system. Though decades of research on group decision-making in educational and social psychology highlight the many limitations associated with group problem solving (e.g. as a result of an over-reliance on heuristics, cognitive biases and ‘groupthink’), a fundamental skill for making decisions and solving problems is the ability to collectively visualise the structure of a shared problem, and use this knowledge to design solutions and strategies for collective action. Results of IM group work from the current case study revealed five core CT skills (clarity of expression, conversational skill, inference, evaluation, and explanation), five CT dispositions (detachment, listening, systematicity, recognising uncertainty, and self-questioning) and fourteen structural relationships among them. The ability to detach, listen and engage in conversation with others, were seen as fundamental drivers of all other competencies in the system. Results are discussed in light of research and theory on CT and best practice for CT instruction.

Item Type: Article
Additional Information: Export Date: 23 February 2015; Correspondence Address: Hogan, M.J.; School of Psychology, NUIIreland; References: Ackoff, R.L., (1981) Creating the corporate future: Plan or be planned for, , John Wiley and Sons, New York:; Alberts, H., Acquisition: Past, present and future (1992) Paper presented at the meeting of the Institute of Management Sciences and Operations Research Society, , Orlando, FL: March; Allen, R., Feezel, J., Kauffeld, F., (1967) A taxonomy of concepts and critical abilities related to the evaluation of verbal arguments (Occasional Paper No. 9), , Wisconsin Research and Development, Center for Cognitive Learning, Madison, WI:; Argyris, C., (1982) Reasoning, learning, and action: Individual and organizational, , Jossey-Bass, San Francisco:; Ashby, W.R., Requisite variety and its implications for the control of complex systems (1958) Cybernetica, 1 (2), pp. 1-17; Association of American Colleges & Universities, (2005) Liberal education outcomes: A preliminary report on student achievement in college, , AAC&U, Washington, DC:; Australian Council for Educational Research, (2002) Graduate skills assessment: Stage one validity study, , Department of Education, Science and Training, Australia:; Banich, M.T., Executive function: The search for an integrated account (2009) Current Directions in Psychological Science, 18 (2), pp. 89-94; Baril, P.B., Cunningham, B.M., Fordham, D.R., Gardner, R.L., Wolcott, S.K., Critical thinking in the public accounting profession: Aptitudes and attitudes (1998) Journal of Accounting Education, 16 (4), pp. 381-406; Bensley, D.A., (1998) Critical thinking in psychology: A unified skills approach, , Brooks & Cole, Pacific Grove, CA:; Bohm, D., A new theory of the relationship of mind and matter (1990) Philosophical psychology, 3 (2-3), pp. 271-286; Boomer, G., Negotiating the curriculum (1992) Negotiating the curriculum: Educating for the 21st century, pp. 4-13. , Boomer G, Lester N, Onore C, Cook J, (eds), Falmer, London:; Boulding, K.E., (1966) The impact of the social sciences, , Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ:; Brabeck, M.M., The relationship between critical thinking skills and development of reflective judgment among adolescent and adult women. Paper presented at the 89th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, Los Angeles (1981) August, pp. 24-26; Bransford, J.D., Brown, A.L., Cocking, R.R., (1999) How people learn: Brain, mind, experience, and school, , National Academy Press, Washington, D.C.:; Broome, B.J., Collective design of the future: Structural analysis of tribal vision statements (1995) American Indian Quarterly, 19, pp. 205-228; Broome, B., The role of facilitated group process in community-based planning and design: Promoting greater participation in Comanche tribal governance (1995) Innovations in group facilitation: Applications in natural settings, pp. 27-52. , Frey LR, (ed), Hampton Press, Cresskill, NJ:; Broome, B.J., Chen, M., Guidelines for computer-assisted group problem-solving: Meeting the challenges of complex issues (1992) Small Group Research, 23, pp. 216-236; Broome, B.J., Cromer, I.L., Strategic planning for tribal economic development: A culturally appropriate model for consensus building (1991) International Journal of Conflict Management, 2, pp. 217-234; Broome, B.J., Fulbright, L., A multi-stage influence model of barriers to group problem solving (1995) Small Group Research, 26, pp. 25-55; Butchart, S., Bigelow, J., Oppy, G., Korb, K., Gold, I., Improving critical thinking using web-based argument mapping exercises with automated feedback (2009) Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 25 (2), pp. 268-291; Christakis, A.N., Systems profile: The Club of Rome revisited (1987) Systems Research, 4, pp. 53-58; Cleveland, H., (1973) The decision makers. Center magazine, 6 (5), pp. 9-18; Coke, J.G., Moore, C.M., Coping with a budgetary crisis: Helping a city council decide where expenditure cuts should be made (1981) Building city council leadership skills: A casebook of models and methods, pp. 72-85. , Burks SW, Wolf JF, (eds), National League of Cities, Washington, DC:; Darling-Hammond, L., How can we teach for meaningful learning? In L. Darling-Hammond (Ed.), Powerful Learning. pp (2008) 1–10; Dawson, T.L., (2008) Metacognition and learning in adulthood, , Developmental Testing Service LLC, Northhampton, MA:; Deal, T.E., Kennedy, A.A., (1982) Corporate cultures: The rites and rituals of corporate life, , Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA:; Delbeq, A.L., Van De Ven, A.H., Gustafson, D.H., (1975) Group techniques for program planning: A guide to nominal group and Delphi processes, , Scott, Foresman, Glenview, IL:; Dewey, J., (1910) How to think, , Heath & Co, Boston:; Dewey, J., (1933) How we think: A restatement of the relation of reflective thinking to the educative process, , Heath & Co, Lexington, MA:; Donnelly, D. F., McGarr, O., & O’Reilly, J. (2014). ‘Just Be Quiet and Listen to Exactly What He’s Saying’: Conceptualising power relations in inquiry-oriented classrooms. International Journal of Science Education, 36(12), 2029–2054Dwyer, C.P., (2011) The evaluation of argument mapping as a learning tool (Doctoral thesis), , Galway: National University of Ireland; Dwyer, C.P., Hogan, M.J., Stewart, I., The promotion of critical thinking skills through argument mapping. In C. P. Horvart & J. M. Forte (Eds.), Critical thinking (pp (2011) 97–122, , New York: Nova Science Publishers; Dwyer, C.P., Hogan, M.J., Stewart, I., An evaluation of argument mapping as a method of enhancing critical thinking performance in e-learning environments (2012) Metacognition and Learning, 7, pp. 219-244; Dwyer, C.P., Hogan, M.J., Stewart, I., An integrated critical thinking framework for the 21st century (2014) Thinking Skills & Creativity, 12, pp. 43-52; Engelmann, T., Baumeister, A., Dingel, A., Hesse, F.W., The added value of communication in a CSCL-scenario compared to just having access to the partners’ knowledge and information (2010) Concept maps making learning meaningful: Proceedings of the 4th international conference on concept mapping, 1, pp. 377-384. , Sánchez J, Cañas A, Novak JD, (eds), University of Chile, Viña del Mar, Chile:; Engelmann, T., Hesse, F.W., How digital concept maps about the collaborators’ knowledge and information influence computer-supported collaborative problem solving (2010) Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning, 5, pp. 299-319; Ennis, R.H., A taxonomoy of critical thinking dispositions and abilities (1987) Teaching thinking skills: Theory and practice, 9-26, , Baron JB, Sternberg RJ, (eds), W.H. Freeman, New York:; Ennis, R.H., (1996) Critical thinking, , Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey:; Ennis, R.H., Is critical thinking culturally biased? (1998) Teaching Philosophy, 21 (1), pp. 15-33; Facione, P.A., (1990) The Delphi report: Committee on pre-college philosophy, , California Academic Press, Millbrae, CA:; Facione, P.A., Facione, N.C., Blohm, S.W., Giancarlo, C.A., (2002) The California critical thinking skills test: CCTST. Form A, form B, and form 2000. Test manual, 2002 updated edition, , Insight Assessment, Millbrae, CA:; Feeg, R., Forum of the future of pediatric nursing: Looking toward the 21st century (1988) Pediatric Nursing, 14, pp. 393-396; Fischer, K.W., A theory of cognitive development: The control and construction of hierarchies of skills (1980) Psychological Review, 87, p. 477; Fischer, K.W., Bidell, T.R., Dynamic development of action, thought, and emotion (2006) Handbook of child psychology: Theoretical models of human development, pp. 313-399. , Damon W, Lerner RM, (eds), 1, Wiley, New York:; Flavell, J., Metacognitive aspects of problem solving (1976) The nature of intelligence, pp. 231-236. , Resnick L, (ed), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, New Jersey:; Gagne, R.M., (1985) Conditions of learning, , Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York:; Glaser, E.M., (1941) An experiment in the development of critical thinking, , Teachers College of Columbia University, Bureau of Publications, New York:; Hake, R., Interactive-engagement vs. traditional methods: A six-thousand student survey of mechanics test data for introductory physics courses (1998) American Journal of Physics, 66 (1), pp. 64-74; Halpern, D.F., (2003) Thought & knowledge: An introduction to critical thinking, , Laurence Erlbaum Associates, New Jersey:; Halpern, D.F., Is intelligence critical thinking? Why we need a new definition of intelligence (2006) Extending intelligence: Enhancement and new constructs, 293–310, , Kyllonen PC, Roberts RD, Stankov L, (eds), Taylor & Francis Group, New York:; Harney, O., Hogan, M.J., Broome, B.J., Collaborative learning: The effects of trust and open and closed dynamics on consensus and efficacy (2012) Social Psychology of Education, 15 (4), pp. 517-532; Higher Education Quality Council, (1996) What are graduates? Clarifying the attributes of “graduateness”, , HEQC, London:; Hogan, M.J., Against didacticism: A psychologist’s view (2006) Educational Research and Reviews, 1 (7), pp. 206-212; Hogan, M. J., Dwyer, C. P., Harney, O. M., Noone, C., & Conway, R. J. (2014). Metacognitive skill development and applied systems science: A framework of metacognitive skills, self-regulatory functions and real-world applications. In Metacognition: Fundaments, applications, and trends. Berlin: SpringerHuffman, K., Vernoy, M., Williams, B., Vernoy, J., (1991) Psychology in action, , John Wiley and Sons, New York:; Huitt, W., Educational Psychology Interactive. Valdosta, GA: Valdosta State University. Retrieved 08/08/2011 (2011) From, ,, Bloom et al.’s taxonomy of the cognitive domain; Hwang, G.J., Shi, Y.R., Chu, H.C., A concept map approach to developing collaborative mindtools for context-aware ubiquitous learning (2011) British Journal of Educational Technology, 42 (5), pp. 778-789; Jukes, I., McCain, T., (2002) Minds in play: Computer game design as a context of children’s learning, , Erlbaum, New Jersey:; Keever, D.B., Cultural complexities in the participative design of a computer-based organization information system. Paper presented at the International Conference on Support, Society and Culture: Mutual Uses of Cybernetics and Science (1989) Amsterdam, , The Netherlands: April; Kemeny, J., Saving American democracy: The lesson of three mile Island (1980) Technology Review, 83 (7), pp. 64-75; King, P.M., Kitchener, K.S., (1994) Developing reflective judgment: Understanding and promoting intellectual growth and critical thinking in adolescents and adults, , Jossey Bass, San Francisco:; Kirschner, P.A., Sweller, J., Clark, R.E., Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: An analysis of the failure of constructivist, discovery, problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching (2006) Educational Psychologist, 41 (2), pp. 75-86; Ku, K.Y.L., Assessing students’ critical thinking performance: Urging for measurements using multi-response format (2009) Thinking Skills and Creativity, 4 (1), pp. 70-76; Ku, K.Y.L., Ho, I.T., Dispositional factors predicting Chinese students’ critical thinking performance (2010) Personality and Individual Differences, 48, pp. 54-58; Kuhn, D., A developmental model of critical thinking (1999) Educational Researcher, 28 (2), pp. 16-25; Lloyd, M., Bahr, N., Thinking critically about critical thinking in higher education (2010) International Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, 4 (2), pp. 1-5; Mayer, R.E., Should there be a three-strikes rule against pure discovery learning? The case for guided methods of instruction (2004) American Psychologist, 59 (1), pp. 14-19; Meyer, B.J.F., Brandt, D.M., Bluth, G.J., Use of top-level structure in text: Key for reading comprehension of ninth-grade students (1980) Reading Research Quarterly, 16 (1), pp. 72-103; Miller, G.A., The magical number seven, plus or minus two: Some limits on our capacity for processing information (1956) Psychology Review, 63, pp. 81-97; Moseley, D., Baumfield, V., Elliot, J., Gregson, M., Higgins, S., Miller, J., Newton, D., (2005) Frameworks for thinking: A handbook for teaching and learning, , Cambridge University Press, Cambridge:; Paul, R., (1993) Critical thinking: What every person needs to survive in a rapidly changing world, , Foundation for Critical Thinking, Rohnert Park, CA:; Perkins, D.N., Ritchhart, R., When is good thinking? (2004) Motivation, emotion, and cognition: Integrative perspectives on intellectual functioning and development, pp. 351-384. , Dai DY, Sternberg RJ, (eds), Erlbaum, Mawah, NJ:; Redish, E., Saul, J., Steinberg, R., On the effectiveness of active-engagement microcomputer-based laboratories (1997) American Journal of Physics, 65 (1), p. 45; Reed, J.H., Kromrey, J.D., Teaching critical thinking in a community college history course: Empirical evidence from infusing Paul’s model (2001) College Student Journal, 35 (2), pp. 201-215; Rimiene, V., Assessing and developing students’ critical thinking (2002) Psychology Learning and Teaching, 2 (1), pp. 17-22; Rittel, H., Webber, M., Dilemmas in a general theory of planning (1974) DMG-DRS Journal, 8, pp. 31-39; Rogoff, B., Cognition as a collaborative process (1998) Handbook of child psychology: Volume 2: Cognition, perception and language, pp. 679-744. , Damon W, (ed), John Wiley & Sons Inc, New Jersey:; Roth, W.M., Roychoudhury, A., Science discourse through collaborative concept mapping: New perspectives for the teacher (1994) International Journal of Science Education, 16, pp. 437-455; Sato, T., Determination of hierarchical networks of instructional units using the ISM method (1979) Educational Technology Research, 3, pp. 67-75; Simon, H.A., (1960) The new science of management decisions, , Harper & Row, New York:; Solon, T., Generic critical thinking infusion and course content learning in introductory psychology (2007) Journal of Instructional Psychology, 34 (2), pp. 95-109; Sweller, J., (1999) Instructional design in technical areas. Australian Education Review No. 43, , Victoria: Acer Press; ACE and NSSE. Retrieved August 28, 2010 (2007) From, ,; Valenzuela, J., Nieto, A.M., Saiz, C., Critical thinking motivational scale: A contribution to the study of relationship between critical thinking and motivation (2011) Journal of Research in Educational Psychology, 9 (2), pp. 823-848; van Eemeren, F.H., Grootendorst, R., Henkemans, F.S., Blair, J.A., Johnson, R.H., Krabbe, E.C.W., Planitin, C., Zarefsky, D., (1996) Fundamentals of argumentation theory: A handbook of historical backgrounds and contemporary developments, , Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, New Jersey:; van Gelder, T.J., Learning to reason: A Reason!Able approach. In C. Davis, T. J. van Gelder & R. Wales (Eds.), Cognitive Science in Australia (2000) 2000: Proceedings of the Fifth Australasian Cognitive Science Society Conference, , Adelaide, Causal:; van Gelder, T.J., How to improve critical thinking using educational technology. In G. Kennedy, M. Keppell, C. McNaught & T. Petrovic (Eds.), Meeting at the Crossroads: Proceedings of the 18th Annual Conference of the Australian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education (pp. 539–548) (2001) Melbourne, , Biomedical Multimedia Unit: University of Melbourne; Vygotsky, L.S., (1978) Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes, , Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA:; Warfield, J.N., (1994) A science of generic design: Managing complexity through systems design, , Intersystems, Salinas, CA:; Warfield, J.N., Cardenas, A.R., (1994) A handbook of interactive management, , The Iowa State University Press, Ames, IA:; Wood, D.J., Bruner, J.S., Ross, G., The role of tutoring in problem solving (1976) Journal of Child Psychiatry and Psychology, 17 (2), pp. 89-100; Wood, P., Kitchener, K., Jensen, L., Considerations in the design and evaluation of a paper-and-pencil measure of epistemic cognition (2002) Personal epistemology: The psychology of beliefs about knowledge and knowing, 1, pp. 277-294
Uncontrolled Keywords: Collective intelligence; Critical thinking; Disposition towards thinking; Interactive management
Depositing User: National Forum
Date Deposited: 05 Dec 2015 09:55
Last Modified: 05 Dec 2015 09:56

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year