Understanding the role of the qualified professional: A comparison of medical and dental students attitudes

Widdifield, H. and Ryan, C. A. and O'Sullivan, E. (2006) Understanding the role of the qualified professional: A comparison of medical and dental students attitudes. Irish Medical Journal, 99 (9). ISSN 03323102 (ISSN)

Full text not available from this resource.


The Royal College of Physicians & Surgeons of Canada developed a competency framework to assist future specialists in responding to challenges as health care providers. The CANMEDs project described 7 essential roles of Specialist Physicians include Health Advocate, Manager, Scholar, Medical Expert, Professional, Communicator and Collaborator (HMSEPC2). The object of the current study was to investigate whether medical students and dental students in Ireland recognised these responsibilities as essential to a qualified doctor/dentist. Methods: Ninety-eight medical and forty-six dental students (year 1 and year 4) were asked to mind map the responsibilities of qualified doctors/dentists. The comments on the mind map were applied to one of the 7 CANMED roles. There were 484 comments from 128 students. Students had the greatest number of responses referring to the Medical and Dental Expert (257, 30.4%) and Professional (227, 26.9%) roles. This was followed by Communicator (130, 15.4%), Scholar (107, 12.7%) an Health Advocate (82, 9.7%) roles. There were relatively few responses relating to Manager (12, 1.4%) and Collaborator (i.e. teamwork) roles (30, 3.6%). There were no differences in responses between Dental Students and Medical Students and between 1st year and 4th year students. Similarly there were no differences between the responses of Irish students (n =95; 68%) and International students (n =45; 32%) Students are aware of their responsibilities as Medical or Dental experts (diagnostic and therapeutic skills) for ethical and effective patient care (professional role). They are somewhat aware of the Communicator (therapeutic relationships and effective listening), Scholar (personal continuing education strategies) and Health Advocate (contribute to improved community health) roles. In general they have little concept of the importance of Management skills (utilising resources effectively), and of Collaboration (teamwork and consulting effectively with other physicians and health care professionals). Medical and Dental Educators and Curriculum Committees should address these important deficiencies. Dental Educators and Curriculum Committees should address these important deficiencies.

Item Type: Article
Additional Information: Export Date: 23 February 2015; CODEN: IMDJB; Correspondence Address: Ryan, C.A.; Erinville Maternity Hospital, Department of Paediatrics and Child Health, Western Road, Cork, Ireland; References: Irvine, D., The performance of doctors: Professionalism and self-regulation in a changing world E 1540Brill, J.R., Ohly, S., Stearns, M.A., Training community-responsive physicians (2002) Acad Med; CANMEDS 2000 project. Skills for the new millennium Annals of the, 29, pp. 206-216. , Societal Needs Working Group; Ende, J., Kelley, M., Sox, H., The Federated Council of Internal Medicine's resource guide for residenc instrument for curricular change (1997) Ann Intern Med, 127, pp. 454-457; Revalidation Folder: Doctors working in clinical general practice in Scotland RCGP Scotland, FGood medical practice (1998), General Medical Council. London: General Medical CouncilLeung, W., Diwakar, V., Competency based medical training: Review. Commentary: The baby is thrown bathwater (2002) Br Med J, 325, pp. 693-696; Ham, C., Alberti, K.G.M., The medical profession, the public, and the government (1997) Br Med J; Buzan, T., Buzan, B., (1974) Mind Mapping; Kalet, A., Pugnaire, M.P., Cole-Kelly, K., Janicik, R., Ferrara, E., Schwartz, M.D., Lipkin, M., Teaching communication in clinical clerkships: Models from the macy initiative in health communications (2004) A Medicine, 79, pp. 511-520; Sackett, D.L., Evidence-based medicine (1997) Seminars in Perinatology, 21, pp. 3-5; Wright, J., Hill, P., (2003) Clinical Governanace, , London: Churchill Livingstone; Lempp, H., Seale, C., The hidden curriculum in undergraduate medical education: Qualitative study of perceptions of teaching (2004) Br Med J, 329, pp. 770-773; Tuhan, I., Mastering CANMEDS roles in psychiatric residency: A resident’ s perspective Can J Ps, pp. 222-224; Ham, C., Alberti, K.G.M.M., The medical profession, the public and the government Br Med J, , 200; Degeling, P., Maxwell, S., Kennedy, J., Coyle, B., Medicine, management, and the modernization (2003) Br Med J, 326, pp. 649-652; Harrison, D., Integrating health sector action on the social and determinants of health (1998), Promotion and Education Online: Verona InitiativeUR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?eid=2-s2.0-37849185359&partnerID=40&md5=6f754292127212d16b5ad03183f75bbd
Uncontrolled Keywords: adult; article; brain mapping; consultation; curriculum; dental student; female; human; human experiment; human relation; male; medical education; medical ethics; medical specialist; medical student; normal human; patient care; professional competence; professional practice; student attitude
Depositing User: National Forum
Date Deposited: 12 Dec 2015 18:13
Last Modified: 12 Dec 2015 18:16
URI: http://eprints.teachingandlearning.ie/id/eprint/3858

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year