Problem-based learning in academic health education. A systematic literature review

Polyzois, I. and Claffey, N. and Mattheos, N. (2010) Problem-based learning in academic health education. A systematic literature review. European Journal of Dental Education, 14 (1). pp. 55-64. ISSN 13965883 (ISSN)

Full text not available from this resource.
Official URL:


Problem based learning (PBL) arguably represents the most significant development in education over the past five decades. It has been promoted as the curriculum of choice, and since its introduction in the 1960's, has been widely adopted by many medical and dental schools. PBL has been the subject of much published literature but ironically, very little high quality evidence exists to advocate its efficacy and subsequently justify the widespread curriculum change. The purpose of this review is to classify and interpret the available evidence and extract relevant conclusions. In addition, it is the intent to propose recommendations regarding the relative benefits of PBL compared with conventional teaching. The literature was searched using PubMed, ERIC and PsycLIT. Further articles were retrieved from the reference lists of selected papers. Articles were chosen and included according to specific selection criteria. Studies were further classified as randomised controlled trials (RCTs) or comparative studies. These studies were then analysed according to intervention type: whole curricula comparisons and single educational interventions of shorter duration. At the level of RCTs and comparative studies (whole curricula), no clear difference was observed between PBL and conventional teaching. Paradoxically, it was only comparative studies of single PBL intervention in a traditional curriculum that yielded results that were consistently in favour of PBL. Further research is needed to investigate the possibility that multiple PBL interventions in a traditional curriculum could be more effective than an exclusively PBL programme. In addition, it is important to address the potential benefits of PBL in relation to life-long learning of health care professionals. © 2010 John Wiley & Sons A/S.

Item Type: Article
Additional Information: Cited By :25; Export Date: 23 February 2015; Correspondence Address: Polyzois, I.; School of Dental Science, Trinity College, Dublin 2, Ireland; email:; References: Albanese, M.A., Mitchell, S., Problem-based learning: A review of literature on its outcomes and implementation issues (1993) Acad Med, 68, pp. 52-81; Vernon, D., Blake, R., Does problem-based learning work? a meta-analysis of evaluative research (1993) Acad Med, 68, pp. 550-563; Berkson, L., Problem-based learning: Have the expectations been met? (1993) Acad Med, 68 (SUPPL. 10), pp. 79-88; Norman, G.R., Schmidt, H.G., The psychological basis of problem-based learning: A review of the evidence (1992) Acad Med, 67, pp. 557-565; Colliver, J., Effectiveness of problem-based learning curricula: Research and theory (2000) Acad Med, 75, pp. 259-266; Peters, A.S., Greenberger-Rosovsky, R., Crowder, C., Long-term outcome of the new pathway program at Harvard Medical School: A randomized controlled trial (2000) Acad Med, 75, pp. 470-479; Shmidt, H.G., Vermeulen, L., Van Der Molen, H., Longterm effects of problem-based learning: A comparison of competencies acquired by graduates of a problem-based and a conventional medical school (2006) Med Educ, 40, pp. 562-567; Newman, M., (2003) Campell Collaboration Systematic Review Group on the Effectiveness of Problem-based Learning. A Pilot Systematic Review and Metaanalysis on the Effectiveness of Problem Based Learning., , Newcastle upon Tyne (UK). University of Newcastle upon Tyne; Dochy, F., Segers, M., Bossche Van Den, P., Effects of PBL: A meta-analysis (2003) Learning and Instruction, 13, pp. 533-568; Koh, G.C., Khoo, H.E., Wong, M.L., The effects of problem based learning during medical school on physician competency: A systematic review (2008) CMAJ, 178, pp. 34-41; Mennin, S.P., Friedman, M., Skipper, B., Performances on the NBME I, II, and III by medical students in the problem-based learning and conventional tracks at the University of New Mexico (1993) Acad Med, 68, pp. 616-624; Moore, G.T., Block, S.D., Style, C.B., The influence of the new pathway curriculum on Harvard medical students (1994) Acad Med, 69, pp. 983-989; Schmidt, H.G., MacHiels-Bongaerts, M., Hermans, H., The development of diagnostic competence: Comparison of a problem-based, an integrated,and a conventional medical curriculum (1996) Acad Med, 71, pp. 658-664; Tans, R.W., Schmidt, H.G., Sturing van het onderwijsleerproces door middel van problemen:een veldexperiment (Guiding the learning process by means of problems: A field experiment) (1986) Tijdschrift voor Onderwijsresearch, 11, pp. 35-46; Antepohl, W., Herzig, S., Problem based learning versus lecture based learning in a course of basic pharmacology: A controlled, randomized study (1999) Med Educ, 33, pp. 106-113; Imbos, T., Drukker, J., Van Mameren, H., The growth in knowledge of anatomy in a problem based curriculum (1984) Tutorials in Problem-based Learning. New Direction in Training for the Health Professions., pp. 106-115. , In. Schmidt, H.G. de Volder, M.L. eds. Assen. Van Gorcum; Coles, C.R., Differences between conventional and problem based curricula in their students approaches to studying (1985) Med Educ, 19, pp. 308-309; Kaufman, A., Mennin, S., Waterman, R., The New Mexico experiment: Educational innovation and institutional change (1989) Acad Med, 64, pp. 285-294; Boshuizen, H.P., Schmidt, H., Curriculum style and the integration of biomedical and clinical knowledge (1993) Problem-based Learning As An Educational Strategy., pp. 33-41. , In. Bouhuys, P.A.J. Schmidt, H. Van, Berkel. eds. Maastricht. Network publications; Shin, J.H., Haynes, R.B., Johnston, M.E., Effect of problem-based, self-directed undergraduate education on life-long learning (1993) CMAJ, 148, pp. 969-976; Mennin, S.P., Kalishman, S., Friedman, M., A survey of graduates in practice from the university of New Mexico's conventional and community-oriented Problem-based Tracks (1996) Acad Med, 71, pp. 1079-1089; Richards, B.F., Ober, K.P., Cariaga-Lo, L., Ratings of students' performances in a third-year internal medicine clerkship: A comparison between problem-based and lecture-based curricula (1996) Acad Med, 71, pp. 187-189; Hmelo, C.E., Problem-based learning: Effects on the early acquisition of cognitive skill in medicine (1998) The Journal of the Learning Sciences, 7, pp. 173-208; Shuler, C.F., Fincham, A.G., Comparative achievement on national dental board examination Part i between dental students in problem based learning and traditional educational tracks (1998) J Dent Educ, 62, pp. 666-670; Blake, R.L., Hosokawa, M.C., Riley, S.L., Student performances on Step 1 and Step 2 of the United States medical licensing examination following implementation of a problem-based learning curriculum (2000) Acad Med, 75, pp. 66-70; Jones, A., McArdles, P.J., O'Neill, P.A.O., Perceptions of how well graduates are prepared for the role of pre-registration house officer: A comparison of outcomes from a traditional and an integrated PBL curriculum (2002) Med Educ, 36, pp. 16-25; Gurpinar, E., Musal, B., Aksakoglu, G., Comparison of knowledge scores of medical students in problem-based learning and traditional curriculum on public health topics (2005) BMC Med Educ, 5, p. 7; Iputo, J.E., Kwizera, E., Problem- based learning improves the academic performance of medical students in South Africa (2005) Med Educ, 39, pp. 399-393; Rich, S.K., Keim, R.G., Shuler, C.F., Problem-based learning versus a traditional educational methodology: A comparison of preclinical and clinical periodontics performance (2005) J Dent Educ, 69, pp. 649-662; Tamblyn, R., Abrahamowicz, M., Dauphinee, D., Effect of a community oriented problem based learning curriculum on quality of primary care delivered by graduates: Historical cohort comparison study (2005) BMJ, 331, pp. 1002-1005; Neufeld, V., Sibley, J., 'Evaluation of health sciences education programs: Programme and student assessment at McMaster University' (1989) New Directions for Medical Education: PBL and Community Oriented Medical Education., pp. 165-179. , In. Schmidt, H. Lipkin, J.R. De Vries, M. De Greep, J. eds. New York. Springer Verlag; Baca, E., Mennin, S.P., Comparison between a problem-based, community oriented track and a traditional track within one medical school (1990) Innovation in Medical Education: An Evaluation of Its Present Status., pp. 9-26. , In. Nooman, Z.M. Schmidt, H.G. Ezzat, E.S. eds. New York. Springer; Woodward, C.A., McAuley, R.G., Can the academic background of medical graduates be detected during intership? (1983) Can Med Assoc J, 129, pp. 567-569; Jones, J.W., Bieber, L.L., Echt, R., A problem based curriculum, ten years of experience (1984) Tutorials in Problem Based Learning. New Direction in Training for Health Professions., pp. 181-198. , In. Schmidt, H.G. de Volder, M.L. eds. Assen. Van Gorcum; Farquhar, L.J., Haf, J., Kotabe, K., Effect of two preclinical curricula on NMBE part i examination performance (1986) J Med Educ, 61, pp. 368-373; Santos-Gomez, L., Kalishman, S., Rezler, A., Residency performance of graduates from a problem-based and a conventional curriculum (1990) Med Educ, 24, pp. 366-375; Goodman, L.J., Brueschke, E.E., Bone, R.C., An experiment in medical education. A critical analysis using traditional criteria (1991) JAMA, 265, pp. 2373-2376; Tolnai, S., Continuing medical education and career choice among graduates of problem-based and traditional curricula (1991) Med Educ, 25, pp. 414-420; Block, S.D., Moore, G.T., Project evaluation (1994) New Pathways to Medical Education: Learning to Learn at Harvard Medical School., pp. 38-114. , In. Tosteson, D.C. Adelstein, S.J. Carver, S.T. eds. Cambridge, MA. Harvard University Press; Rolfe, I.E., Andren, J.M., Pearson, S., Hensley, M.J., Gordon, J.J., Clinical competency of interns (1995) Med Educ, 29, pp. 225-230; Albano, M., Cavallo, G.F., Hoogenboom, R., An international comparison of knowledge levels of medical students: The Maastricht Progress Test (1996) Med Educ, 30, pp. 239-245; Login, G.R., Ransil, B.J., Meyer, M., Assessment of preclinical problem-based learning versus lecture-based learning (1997) J Dent Educ, 61, pp. 473-479; Distlehorst, L.H., Robbs, R.S., A comparison of problem-based learning and standard curriculum students: Three years of retrospective data (1998) Teach Learn Med, 10, pp. 131-137; Kaufman, D.M., Mann, K.V., Comparing achievement on the medical council of Canada qualifying examination Part i of students in conventional and Problem-based Learning curricula (1998) Acad Med, 73, pp. 1211-1213; Verhoeven, B.H., Verwijnen, G.M., Scherpbier, A.J.J.A., An analysis of progress test results of PBL and non-PBL students (1998) Med Teach, 20, pp. 310-316; Last, K.S., Appleton, J., Stevenson, H., Basic science knowledge of dental students on conventional and problem-based learning (PBL) courses at Liverpool (2001) Eur J Dent Educ, 5, pp. 148-154; Prince, K.J., Van Eijs, P.W., Boshuizen, H.P., General competencies of problem-based learning (PBL) and non-PBL graduates (2005) Med Educ, 39, pp. 394-401; Barrows, H.S., Tamblyn, R.M., An evaluation of problem based learning in small groups utilizing a simulated patient (1976) J Med Educ, 51, pp. 52-54; Nolte, J., Eller, P., Ringel, S.P., Shifting toward problem-based learning in a medical school neurobiology course (1988) Res Med Educ, 27, pp. 66-71; Eisenstaedt, R.S., Barry, W.E., Glanz, K., Problem-based learning: Cognitive retention and cohort traits of randomly selected participants and decliners (1990) Acad Med, 65 (SUPPL. 9), pp. 11-12; Hmelo, C.E., Gotterer, G.S., Bransford, J.D., A theory driven approach to assessing the cognitive effects of PBL (1997) Instr Sci, 25, pp. 387-408; Schwartz, R.W., Burgett, J.E., Blue, A.V., PBL and performance-based testing: Effective alternatives for undergraduate surgical education and assessment of student performance (1997) Med Teach, 19, pp. 19-23; McParland, M., Noble, L.M., Livingstone, G., The effectiveness of problem-based learning compared to traditional teaching in undergraduate psychiatry (2004) Med Educ, 38, pp. 859-867; Michel, M.C., Bischoff, A., Heringdorf, D.Z., Neumann, D., Jakobs, K.H., Problem- vs. lecture-based pharmacology teaching in a German medical school (2002) Naunyn-Schmiedeberg's Archives of Pharmacology, 366 (1), pp. 64-68. , DOI 10.1007/s00210-002-0570-x; Torgerson, C., Educational research and randomised trials (2002) Med Educ, 36, pp. 1002-1003; Norman, G., Schmidt, H., Effectiveness of problem based learning curricula: Theory, practice and paper darts (2000) Med Educ, 34, pp. 721-728; Prideaux, D., Researching the outcomes of educational interventions: A matter of design (2002) BMJ, 324, pp. 126-127; Albanese, M.A., Problem-based learning "why curricula are likely to show little effect on knowledge and clinical skills" (2000) Med Educ, 34, pp. 729-738; Ferguson, K.J., Problem-based learning: Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater (2005) Med Educ, 39, pp. 352-353; Morrison, J., Where now for problem based learning (2004) Lancet, 363, p. 174; Schmidt, H.G., Problem-based learning: Does it prepare medical students to become better doctors? (1998) Med J Aust, 168, pp. 429-430; Winning, T., Townsend, G., Problem-based learning in dental education: What's the evidence for and against...and is it worth the effort? (2007) Aust Dent J, 52, pp. 2-9; Schwartz, L.P., Egan, A.G., Heath, C.J., How one school obtained the benefits of problem based learning without revolution (1993) Acad Med, 68, pp. 612-613; Dolmans, D., The effectiveness of PBL: The debate continues. Some concerns about the BEME movement (2003) Med Educ, 37, pp. 1129-1130; Mamede, S., Schmidt, H.G., Norman, G.R., Innovations in problem-based learning: What can we learn from recent studies? (2006) Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 11, pp. 403-422; Newman, M., Van Den Bossche, P., Gijbels, D., Responces to the pilot systematic review of problem-based learning (2004) Med Educ, 38, pp. 921-926
Uncontrolled Keywords: Conventional; Didactic Instruction; Effectiveness; Problem based learning; Traditional; article; clinical competence; curriculum; human; methodology; randomized controlled trial; teaching; vocational education; Education, Professional; Humans; Problem-Based Learning; Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic
Depositing User: National Forum
Date Deposited: 10 Dec 2015 21:11
Last Modified: 10 Dec 2015 21:17

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year