The response of higher and technological education to changing patterns of employment

Heywood, J. (2012) The response of higher and technological education to changing patterns of employment. [Conference Proceedings]

Full text not available from this resource.
Official URL:


Educational policy making is seldom discussed at meetings of engineering educators except in so far as they relate to implementation, as for example the response to ABET 2000 or the Bologna Agreement. It is widely believed among engineering educators that there is a continuing shortage of highly qualified engineers and scientists. Public acceptance of this view ensures continued high levels of funding. Coupled to this axiom is the supply side view that an insufficient number of quality candidates are emerging from the schools as candidates for STEM courses. Such views are not confined to the United States but will be found in other industrialised nations. Relatively little attention is paid to the demand side of the equation. However, the data that is available challenges these axioms and suggests that while there may be specific shortages there is no general shortage. It is noted that there are numbers of middle-aged engineers who are unemployed. It is also noted that technological innovation does not guarantee an increase in employment as in the past, and that in the extreme case technology may create a new technology without reference to the work force. Most complaints from employers about the products of higher education do not focus on their technical knowledge but on their failure to develop what in the UK have been called personal transferable skills. The implications of findings for educational policy makers are (1) that policy making should be undertaken from a systems perspective that embraces elementary education at one end of the spectrum and lifelong (permanent) education at the other: (2) that engineering educators together with industrialists should pay much more attention to lifelong education, and therefore in continuing professional development for engineers in both technical and personal dimensions: (3) that engineering educators should better prepare students with the skills of flexibility and adaptability required to cope with ever changing knowledge, that is personal transferable skills. These axioms are reinforced by a recent report from the National Governors Association in the US that from an evaluation of changing patterns of employment and skill demands, recommends that the states should pay much more attention to the needs of employers. In so doing the authors challenge the states to reduce the traditional emphasis on four-year liberal arts programmes and focus more on job (vocationally) oriented courses. There is a responsibility on those engaged in engineering literacy to consider how it might act as a bridge between these apparently opposing philosophies. © 2012 American Society for Engineering Education.

Item Type: Conference Proceedings
Additional Information: Conference code: 91898; Export Date: 23 February 2015; Correspondence Address: Heywood, J.; Trinity College DublinIreland; References: Heywood, J., (2008) Curriculum and Curriculum Leadership. Towards Inquiry Oriented Schools, p. 306. , Original Writing for National Association for Principals and Deputies, Dublin; Lécuyer, C., (2007) Making Silicon Valley. Innovation and the Growth of High Tech, 1930-1970, , The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA; The Engineer of 2020. Visions of Engineering in the New Century, , National Academy of Engineering. National Academies Press, Washington, DC; Kourdi, J., The future is not what it used to be (2010) The Professional Manager, 19 (2), pp. 27-28. , Chartered Management Institute; Gregory, S.A., Monk, J.D., Creativity: Definitions and models (1972) Creativity in Innovation and Engineering, , S. A. Gregory (ed). Butterworths, London; (1945) Higher Technological Education, , Report of a Committee Chaired by Lord Eustace Percy. Privy Council, London; Payne, G.L., (1960) Britain's Scientific and Technological Manpower, , Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA; Sheppard, S.D., MacAtangay, K., Colby, A., Sullivan, W.M., (2009) Educating Engineers. Designing for the Future of the Field, , Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching. Jossey-Bass, San Fransisco. See ch 3 for a brief history; Akera, A., Liberal learning revisited: A historical examination of the underlying reasons, frustrations and continued prospects of engineering and liberal arts integration (2011) Proceedings ASEE Annual Conference and Exposition, , Paper 1117. ISBN 978-0-87823-234-5. American Society for Engineering Education; Teitelbaum, M.S., Do we need more scientists ? (2003) The Public Interest. No 153, , National Affairs Inc Washington DC; Kelly, T.K., Butz, W.P., Carroll, S., Adamson, D.M., Bloom, G., The US Scientific and Technical Workforce. Improving Data for Decision Making, pp. 11-31. , Organized by Rand Science and Technology; (1960) Advancement of Science, 67; Lowell, B.L., Salzman, H., (2007) Into the Eye of the Storm: Assessing the Evidence on Science and Engineering Education, Quality, and Workforce Demand, , Urban Institute. 48 pages; First Bell. Today's Engineering and Technology News under the Heading, , ASEE, Washington, DC; Patel, P., Where the engineering jobs are. the news is good but not great for engineers looking for work in 2010 (2010) IEEE Spectrum, , Downloaded 03:01:2012; Ellis, R.A., (2007) Effects of Recent Revisions in Federal Standard Occupational Classification (SOC) Categories of the Employment of STEM Professionals, , Commission on Professionals in Science and Technology. New York; Future of STEM curricula and instructional design (2009) A Blue Sky Workshop, , December 1 - 3. Center for the Study of the Mathematics Curriculum; Blau, J., Germany faces shortage of engineers IEEE Prism, , updated 19:08:2011. Downloaded 03:01:2012; Schneiderman, Economy and shortages affect European job outlook. The bigger high-tech companies in Europe are recruiting EE's. Talent is in short supply, especially to smaller firms looking for very specific skills (2010) IEEE Spectrum, , March; Becker, S.F., Why don't young people want to become engineers? Rational reasons for disappointing decisions (2010) European Journal of Engineering Education, 35 (4), pp. 349-366; Hamilton, A., This postgraduate brain drain needs plugging (2012) The Times, p. 18. , March 1 st; (2011) Winter Issue. (Chartered Management Institute), p. 12; Wu, C., (2011) ASEE Prism, p. 40. , November; (2011) The Professional Manager, , Winter. Chartered Management Institute; Zachary, G.P., Jobless innovation? (2011) IEEE Spectrum, p. 8. , April; Wadhwa, V., Leading edge: Over the hill at 40 (2011) ASEE Prism, p. 32; Zachary, G.P., Jobless innovation? (2011) IEEE Spectrum, p. 8. , April; Clifton, J., (2011) The Coming Jobs War, , Gallup Press, New York; Sparks, E., Waits, M.J., Degrees for what jobs? Raising expectations for universities and colleges in a global economy (2011) National Governors Association, p. 20. , 23; (2009) Report on Higher Education, , Minnesota Measures. Minnesota Office of Higher Education; Sparks, E., Waits, M.J., (2011) Degrees for What Jobs? Raising Expectations for Universities and Colleges in A Global Economy, , National Governors Association; Schneider, C.G., President's message. Deepening the connections: Liberal education and global learning (2011) Liberal Education, 97 (3-4). ,, downloaded 22: 01: 2012; Tomorrow's Professor(sm) Email Newsletter, , http://cqii.stanfordedu/dept-cqi-bintomprofpostings.php; Thomas, B., Madigan, C., Strategy and job choice after redundancy: A case study in the aircraft industry (1974) Sociological Review, 22, pp. 83-102; Youngman, M.B., Octoby, R., Monk, J.D., Heywood, J., (1978) Analysing Jobs, , Gower Press, Aldershot; Heywood, J., (2005) Engineering Education. Research and Development in Curriculum and Instruction, pp. 42-49. , IEEE/Wiley Interscience, Hoboken, NJ; Heywood, J., (1994) Enterprise Learning and Its Assessment in Higher Education, , Technical Report No 20. Employment Department, Sheffield
Uncontrolled Keywords: ABET 2000; Continuing professional development; Demand-side; Educational policy; Elementary education; Engineering educators; Higher education; Liberal arts; National Governors Association; Policy making; Public acceptance; Side view; Technological innovation; Transferable skills; Work force; Decision making; Employment; Engineering; Engineers; Exhibitions; Philosophical aspects; Students; Technical presentations; Engineering education
Depositing User: National Forum
Date Deposited: 08 Dec 2015 21:25
Last Modified: 08 Dec 2015 21:25

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year