The role of prior mathematical experience in predicting mathematics performance in higher education

Faulkner, F. and Hannigan, A. and Fitzmaurice, O. (2014) The role of prior mathematical experience in predicting mathematics performance in higher education. International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 45 (5). pp. 648-667. ISSN 0020739X (ISSN)

Full text not available from this resource.
Official URL:


Evidence of deficiencies in basic mathematical skills of beginning undergraduates has been documented worldwide. Many different theories have been set out as to why these declines in mathematical competency levels have occurred over time. One such theory is the widening access to higher education which has resulted in a less mathematically prepared profile of beginning undergraduates than ever before. In response to this situation, the present study details the examination of a range of methods through which a student's mathematical performance in higher education could be predicted at the beginning of their third-level studies. Several statistical prediction methods were examined and the most effective method in predicting students' mathematical performance was discriminant analysis. The discriminant analysis correctly classified 71.3% of students in terms of mathematics performance. An ability to carry out such a prediction in turn allows for appropriate mathematics remediation to be offered to students predicted to fail third-level mathematics. The results of the prediction of mathematical performance, which was carried out using a database consisting of over 1000 beginning undergraduates over a 3-year period, are detailed in this article along with the implications of such findings to educational policy and practice. © 2013 © 2013 Taylor & Francis.

Item Type: Article
Additional Information: Export Date: 23 February 2015; Correspondence Address: Faulkner, F.; Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland; email:; References: Breen, S., Cleary, J., O'Shea, A., An investigation of the mathematical literacy of first year third-level students in the Republic of Ireland (2009) Int J Math Educ Sci Technol., 40, pp. 229-246; (2006) Assessing scientific, reading and mathematical literacy: A framework for PISA 2006, , Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris,: OECD Publishing; Measuring the mathematics problem (2000), Engineering Council (London)Hourigan, M., O'Donoghue, J., Mathematical under-preparedness: the influence of the pre-tertiary mathematics experience on students' ability to make a successful transition to tertiary level mathematics courses in Ireland (2007) Int J Math Educ Sci Technol., 38, pp. 461-476; Belward, S.R., Mullamphy, D.F.T., Read, W.W., Sneddon, G.E., Preparation of students for tertiary studies requiring mathematics (2007) Aust N Z Ind Appl Math., 47, pp. 840-857; (1995) Third international mathematics and science study, , Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study, Boston (MA),: International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement; Workplace relations and education (2007) Quality of School Education, , Australia Parliament Senate Standing Committee on Employment,: Government reports, Australia; Smaglik, P., NSF calls for funding boost in a bid to reverse decline in maths (2000) Nature, 407, p. 931; Weiss, K.R., Many Cal state freshmen lack math, English skills (1997) Los Angeles Times, , March 20, Sect. A:3-A:17; Seymour, E., Tracking the processes of change in US undergraduate education in science, mathematics, engineering, and technology (2002) Sci Educ., 86, pp. 79-105; Kajander, A., Lovric, M., Transition from secondary to tertiary mathematics: McMaster University experience (2005) Int J Math Educ Sci Technol., 36, pp. 149-160; Tackling the mathematics problem (1995), London Mathematics Society, Southend-on-Sea,: LMS, IMA, RSSDearing, S.R., (1995) Review of 16-19 qualifications, , London,: COI; Kitchen, A., The changing profile of entrants to mathematics at a level and to mathematical subjects in higher education (1999) Br Educ Res J., 25, pp. 57-74; Lawson, D., Changes in student entry competencies 1991-2001 (2003) Teach Math Appl., 22, pp. 171-175; Mulhern, G., Wylie, J., Changing levels of numeracy and other core mathematical skills among psychology undergraduates between 1992 and 2002 (2004) Br J Psychol., 95, pp. 355-370; Ní Ríordán, M., Hannigan, A., Who teaches mathematics at second level in Ireland? (2011) Irish Educ Stud., 30, pp. 289-304; O'Donoghue, J., An intervention to assist at risk students in service mathematics courses at the University of Limerick (1999), Limerick (Ireland),: University of LimerickAllen, J., Robbins, S., Casillas, A., Oh, I., Third-year college retention and transfer: effects of academic performance, motivation, and social connectedness (2008) Res High Educ., 49, pp. 647-664; (2010) A study of progression in Irish higher education [Internet], ,, Higher Education Authority, cited 2011 Apr 11, Available from; Leathwood, C., O'Connell, P., It's a struggle': the construction of the 'new student' in higher education (2003) J Educ Policy., 18, pp. 597-615; Gallagher, J., Osborne, M., Postle, G., Increasing and widening access to higher education: a comparative study of policy and provision in Scotland and Australia (1996) Int J Lifelong Educ., 15, pp. 418-437; Scott, P., (1995) The meaning of mass higher education, , Open University Press; Faulkner, F., Gill, O., Hannigan, A., O'Donoghue, J., Trends in the mathematical competency of university entrants in Ireland by leaving certificate mathematics grade (2010) Teach Math Appl, 29 (2), pp. 76-93; O'Reilly, P., (2008) The evolution of university access programmes in Ireland [Internet], ,, Dublin (Ireland),: University College Dublin, cited 2011 Apr 22]. Available from; Achieving equality of access to higher education in Ireland: action plan 2005-2007 (2005), p., pp. 33-43. , Department of Education and Science, Dublin (Ireland),: Dublin Government Statutory Office NewsletterBaum, S., Ma, J., Payea, K., Education pays: the benefit of higher education for individuals and society (2007) Trends in Education Series, , New York (NY),: The College Board; The path forward: the future of graduate education in the United States (2010), Educational Testing Service and the Council of Graduate SchoolsLiu, H.-C., Andre, T., Greenbowe, T., The impact of learner's prior knowledge on their use of chemistry simulations: a case study (2008) J Sci Educ Technol., 17, pp. 466-482; Lewis, B., Widening participation in higher education: the HEFCE perspective on policy and progress (2002) High Educ Q., 56, pp. 204-219; Inglis, T., Murphy, M., No room for adults? A study of mature students in university college Dublin (1999) Report prepared for the Higher Education Authority, , Dublin (Ireland),: University College Dublin; (2006) Annual competitiveness report volume 2: Ireland's competitiveness challenge, , National Competitiveness Council, Dublin (Ireland),: Forfas for National Competitiveness Council; DesJardins, S.L., Ahlburg, D.A., McCall, B.P., A temporal investigation of factors related to timely degree completion (2002) J High Educ., 73, pp. 555-581; Gill, O., O'Donoghue, J., Hannigan, A., Faulkner, F., Trends in performance of science and technology students (1997-2008) in Ireland (2010) Int J Math Educ Sci Technol., 41, pp. 323-339; Pokorny, M., Pokorny, H., Widening participation in higher education: student quantitative skills and independent learning as impediments to progression (2005) Int J Math Educ Sci Technol., 36, pp. 445-467; Walker, L., Matthew, B., Black, F., Widening access and student non-completion: an inevitable link? Evaluating the effects of the top-up programme on student completion (2004) Int J Lifelong Educ., 23, pp. 43-59; Bamber, J., Tett, L., Transforming the learning experiences of non-traditional students: a perspective from higher education (2000) Stud Contin Educ., 22, pp. 57-75; Watt, S., Paterson, L.C., Pathways and partnerships: widening access to higher education (2000) J Further High Educ., 24, pp. 107-116; (2012) Project maths: Responding to current debate [Internet], ,, National Council for curriculum and Assessment, Dublin (Ireland), cited Nov 2012]. Available from; Bahr, P.R., Does mathematics remediation work? A comparative analysis of academic attainment among community college students (2008) Res High Educ., 49, pp. 420-450; Roueche, J.E., Roueche, S.D., Ely, E.D., Pursuing excellence: the Community College of Denver (2001) Community Coll J Res Pract., 25, pp. 517-537; Saxon, D.P., Boylan, H.R., The cost of remedial education in higher education (2001) J Dev Educ., 25, pp. 2-8; Brothen, T., Wambach, C.A., Refocusing developmental education (2004) J Dev Educ., 28, pp. 16-33; Day Jr., P.R., McCabe, R.H., (1997) Remedial education: A social and economic imperative, , Washington (DC),: American Association of Community Colleges; McCabe, R.H., (2003) Yes we can!: A community college guide for developing America's underprepared, , Phoenix (AZ),: League for Innovation in Community College; Bowl, M., Experiencing the barriers: non-traditional students entering higher education (2001) Res Papers Educ., 16, pp. 141-160; Golding, G., O'Donoghue, J., A constructive approach to identifying the mathematical knowledge gaps of adults learning advanced mathematics (2005) Proceedings of the first National Conference in Mathematics Education, pp. 278-293. , Dublin (Ireland),: St. Patricks College; Murphy, H., Roopchand, N., Intrinsic motivation and self-esteem in traditional and mature students at a post-1992 university in the north-east of England (2003) Educ Stud., 29 (2-3), pp. 243-259; Smith, J., Learning styles: fashion fad or lever for change? The application of learning style theory to inclusive curriculum delivery (2002) Innov Educ Teach Int., 39, pp. 63-70; Gill, O., Mac an Bhaird, C., Ni Fhlionn, E., The origins, development and evaluation of mathematics support services (2010) Irish Math Soc Bull., 66; Herzog, S., Measuring determinants of student return vs. dropout/stop-out vs. transfer: a first-to-second year analysis of new freshmen (2005) Res High Educ., 46, pp. 883-928; Wang, X., Baccalaureate attainment and college persistence of community college transfer students at four-year institutions (2009) Res High Educ., 50, pp. 570-588; Hagedorn, L.S., Siadat, V.S., Fogel, S.F., Nora, A., Pascarella, E.T., Success in college mathematics: comparisons between remedial and non-remedial first-year college students (1999) Res High Educ., 40, pp. 261-283; Liu, X., Whitford, M., Opportunities-to-learn at home: profiles of students with and without reaching science proficiency (2011) J Sci Educ Technol., 20, pp. 375-387; Barry, S.I., Chapman, J., Predicting university performance (2007) Aust N Z Ind Appl Math., 49, pp. 36-50; Belcheir, M.J., What predicts success in intermediate algebra? Research report 2002-2006 (2002) NIH publication no. BSU-RR-2002-06, , Boise (ID),: Boise State University; Mc Donald, B., Predicting mathematical aptitude for higher education (2008) Int J Math Educ Sci Technol., 39, pp. 293-299; Sheel, S.J., Renner, R.S., Dawsey, S.K., Alternatives to math placement exams: a look at discriminant analysis, neural networks, and ensembles of networks (2002), Conway (SC),: Department of Computer Science, Coastal Carolina UniversityGrimes, S.K., David, K.C., Underprepared community college students: implications of attitudinal and experiential differences (1999) Community Coll Rev., 27, pp. 73-92; Waxman, H.C., Padron, Y.N., Improving the quality of classroom instruction for students at risk of failure in urban schools (1995) Peabody J Educ., 70, pp. 44-65; Hyde, J.S., Fennema, E., Lamon, S.J., Gender differences in mathematics performance: a meta-analysis (1990) Psychol Bull., 107, pp. 139-155; Attainment by gender and language context [Internet] (2011),, Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study, Available fromPayzant, E.J., Wolf, D.P., Piloting pacesetter: helping at-risk students meet high standards (1993) Educ Leadersh., 50, pp. 42-45; Pascarella, E., Terenzini, P., (2005) How college affects students. Vol. 2, A third decade of research, , San Francisco (CA),: Jossey-Bass
Uncontrolled Keywords: changing profile; declining standards; mathematics problem; predicting performance; remediation; widening access
Depositing User: Colin Lowry
Last Modified: 27 Nov 2015 02:39

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year