Changing institutional identities of the student nurse

Brennan, D. and Timmins, F. (2012) Changing institutional identities of the student nurse. pp. 747-751. ISSN 02606917 (ISSN)

[img] Text
Brennan and Timmins 2012 1-s2.0-S0260691712001736-main.pdf

Download (192kB)
Official URL:


This paper emphasises the tensions between the ideal of the compliant within care settings and the ideal of the critical thinker within the university setting with reference to student nurse education and identity. Identity is an important part of who we are as people. While modernisation and increased professionalisation of nursing have impacted on staff and patients mostly in a positive way, changes in the management of nursing education in the past 20. years have also heralded a remarkable change in the student identity. Historically informed by association with a particular hospital or health service provider, student nurse identity was shaped by institutional rituals and routine, physically embodied in objects such as uniforms and hospital medals and informed by claims to honesty, virtue and personal integrity (Bradby, 1990). Once part of the structure and fabric of hospital life, nursing students functioned as part of the health care service. As such, their identity was synonymous with that of practicing nurses, whose learning needs were secondary to that of the organisational needs. While this social milieu provided the platform for the formation of institutional pride, belonging and identity, such forms of identity can result in institutional compliance; with the associated risk of ritualistic practice, poor levels of transparent accountability and barriers to whistle blowing should substandard practice arise. Increased student freedom and an emphasis on teaching and learning within the university setting may have benefitted students, patients and the profession, however, the potential impact on student identity is less certain. There is evidence to suggest that students are ill-equipped for their professional identity once qualified and thus require more support for this within universities. This paper explores the tensions between traditional hospital identity and contemporary university identity with reference to student nurse education. The ideal of the compliant versus the ideal of the critical thinker will be debated. © 2012 Elsevier Ltd.

Item Type: Article
Additional Information: Cited By :3; Export Date: 23 February 2015; Correspondence Address: Timmins, F.; The School of Nursing and Midwifery, Trinity College Dublin, 24 Dolier St, Dublin 2, Ireland; email:; References: (2008) The Essentials of Baccalaureate Education for Professional Nursing Practice, ,, American Association of Colleges of Nursing, USA, available at, American Association of Colleges of Nursing, pdf accessed 28th February 2012; Hallmarks of the professional nursing practice environment, ,, available at:, accessed 25th March 2011, American Association of Colleges of Nursing; Björkström, M.E., Athlin, E.E., Johansson, I.S., Nurses' development of professional self-from being a nursing student in a baccalaureate programme to an experienced nurse (2008) Journal of Clinical Nursing, 17 (10), pp. 1380-1391; Blume, J., Student experiences in the real world of nursing I was motivated to challenge the uncaring attitudes of staff (2008) Nursing Standard, 23, p. 6; Bradby, M., Status passage into nursing: another view of the process of socialization into nursing (1990) Journal of Advanced Nursing, 15, pp. 1120-1125; Brennan, D., "Telling stories about ourselves": historical methodology and the creation of mental health nursing narratives (2011) Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 18 (8), pp. p657-p663; Castle, J., The development of professional nursing in New South Wales, Australia (1987) Nursing History: The State of the Art, pp. 9-32. , Aspen Publications, Kent, S. Maggs (Ed.); Clark, C.M., Faculty field guide for promoting student civility in the classroom (2009) Nurse Educator, 34, pp. 5194-5197; Cook, T.H., Gilmer, M.J., Bess, J., Beginning students' definitions of nursing: an inductive framework of professional identity (2003) Journal of Nursing Education, 42 (7), pp. 311-317; Crawford, P., Brown, B., Majomi, P., Professional identity in community mental health nursing: a thematic analysis (2008) International Journal of Nursing Studies, 45 (7), pp. 1055-1063; (1980) Re-Writing Nursing History, , Croom Helm, London, C. Davies (Ed.); Davis, F., Olese, V.L., Initiation into a women's profession: identity problems in the status transition of coed to student nurses (1963) Sociometry, 26 (1), pp. 89-101. , (March); du Toit, D.D., A sociological analysis of the extent and influence of professional socialization on the development of a nursing identity among nursing students at two universities in Brisbane, Australia (1995) Journal of Advanced Nursing, 21, pp. 164-171; Fealy, G.M., McNamara, M., A discourse analysis of debates surrounding the entry of nursing into higher education in Ireland (2007) International Journal of Nursing Studies, 44 (7), pp. 1187-1195; Foucault, M., (1967) Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason, , Tavistock, Great Britain; Foucault, M., (1973) The Birth of the Clinic, , Tavistock, Great Britain; Gibbons, C., Dempster, M., Moutray, M., Stress and eustress in nursing students (2008) Journal of Advanced Nursing, 61 (3), pp. 282-290; Goffman, E., (1959) The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life, , Penguin, Harmondsworth; Goffman, E., (1961) Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates, , Anchor Books & Co., U.S.A; Gorostidi, X.Z., Egilegor, X.H., Mari Jose Alberdi Erice, M.J.A., Iturriotz, M.J.U., Garate, I.M., Lasa, M.B., Xabier Sanz Cascante, X.S., Stress sources in nursing practice. Evolution during nursing training (2007) Nurse Education Today, 27, pp. 777-787; Grealish, L., Trevitt, C., Developing a professional identity: student nurses in the workplace (2005) Contemporary Nurse: A Journal for the Australian Nursing Profession, 19 (1-2), pp. 137-150; Hamilton, H., New graduate identity: discursive mismatch (2005) Contemporary Nurse: A Journal for the Australian Nursing Profession, 20 (1), pp. 66-67; Helmich, E., Dersken, E., Prevoo, M., Laan, R., Bolhuis, S., Koopmans, R., Medical students' professional identity in an early nursing attachment (2010) Medical Education, 44, pp. 674-682; Holton, R., Max Weber and the interpretative tradition (2003) Handbook of Historical Sociology, pp. 27-38. , Sage, London, G. Delanty, E.F. Isin (Eds.); Idczak, S.E., I am a nurse: nursing students learn the art and science of nursing (2007) Nursing Education Perspectives, 28 (2), pp. 66-71; Illich, I., (1976) Limits to Medicine, Medical Nemesis: The Expropriation of Health, , Marion Boyars Publishers Ltd, London; Jones, A., Still crazy after all these years (2007) Nurse Education Today, 27, pp. 365-366; Kalb, K.B., Cherry, N.M., Kauzloric, J., Brender, A., Green, K., Miyagawa, L., Shinoda-Mettler, A., A competency-based approach (2006) Public Health Nursing, 23, pp. 2115-2138; Kalberg, S., (1994) Max Weber's comparative-historical sociology, , Polity Press, Cambridge; Khomeiran, R.T., Yetka, Z.P., Kiger, A.M., Ahmadi, F., Professional competence: factors described by nurses as influencing their development (2006) International Nursing Review, 53 (1), pp. 66-72; Levett-Jones, T., Lathlean, J., McMillan, M., Higgins, I., Belongingness: a montage of nursing students' stories of their clinical placement experiences (2007) Contemporary Nurse: A Journal for the Australian Nursing Profession, 24 (2), pp. 162-174; Levett-Jones, T., Lathlean, J., Higgins, I., McMillan, M., Staff-student relationships and their impact on nursing students' belongingness and learning (2009) Journal of Advanced Nursing, 65 (2), pp. 316-324; Livsey, K.R., Structural empowerment and professional nursing practice behaviours of baccalaureate nursing students in clinical learning environments (2009) International Journal of Nursing Education Scholarship, 6 (1), pp. 1-16; Mackintosh, C., Caring: the socialisation of pre-registration student nurses: a longitudinal qualitative descriptive study (2006) International Journal of Nursing Studies, 43 (8), pp. 953-962; Martin, L., A tale of two placements - from pariah to valued team member (2008) Nursing Standard, 22 (43), p. 29; McAllister, M., John, T., Gray, M., In my day: using lessons from history professional identity (2009) Nurse Education in Practice, 9, pp. 277-283; McLaughlin, K., Muldoon, O.T., Moutray, M., Gender, gender roles and completion of nursing education: a longitudinal study (2010) Nurse Education Today, 30 (4), pp. 303-307; Melia, K.M., Learning and working. The occupational socialisation of nurses (1998) Classic Texts in HealthCare, , Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford, L. Mackay, K. Soothill, K.M. Melia (Eds.); Murphy, F., Jones, S., Edwards, M., James, J., Mayer, A., The impact of nurse education on the caring behaviours of nursing students (2008) Nurse Education Today, 29 (2), pp. 254-264; Newman, J.H., (1873) The Idea of the University, , Basil Montagu Pickering, London; Paton, B.I., The professional practice knowledge of nurse preceptors (2009) Journal of Nursing Education, 49 (3), pp. 143-149; Porter, S., Vain aspirations (1990) Nursing Times, 86 (11), pp. 46-47; Porter, S., (1992) The poverty of professionalisation: a critical analysis of strategies for the occupational advancement of nursing Journal of Advanced Nursing, 17, pp. 720-726; (1998) A Blue Print for the Future, , Government of Ireland, Dublin, Report of the Commission on Nursing; (1990) Identity: Community, Culture, Difference, , Lawrence & Wishart, London, J. Rutherford (Ed.); Shardlow, S.M., Doel, M., Health and social care: a complex context of professional education (2009) Educating Professionals: Practice Learning in Health and Social Care, , Ashgate Publishing Limited, Surrey, M. Doel, S.M. Shardlow (Eds.); Sharif, F., Masoumi, S., A qualitative study of nursing student experiences of clinical practice (2005) BMC Nursing, 4 (6), pp. 4-6. ,, available at; Snodgrass, M.E., (1999) Historical Encyclopaedia of Nursing, , ABC Clio, Oxford; Sohal, A., Negotiating identities: second generation South Asian women's endogamous marital relationships University of British Columbia (2009),,%20A..pdf?sequence=1, Unpublished MSc Thesis available at: accessed 28th February 2012Solbrekke, T.D., Jensen, K., Learning the moral order of professions: the contrasting approaches of nursing and clinical psychology (2006) Learning in Health and Social Care, 5 (4), p. 181; Taylor, S., Who do we think we are? Identities in everyday life (2009) Making Social Lives, pp. 165-202. , The Open University, Milton Keynes, S. Taylor, S. Hinchliffe, J. Clarke, S. Bromley (Eds.); Turner, B.S., (1995) Medical Power and Social Knowledge, , Sage Publications Ltd., London; Watts, J.H., Waraker, S.M., When is a student not a student? Issues of identity and conflict on a distance learning work-based education programme (2008) Learning in Health and Social Care, 7 (2), pp. 105-113; The relation of dress to art. A note in black and white on Mr. Whistler's lecture (1885) Pall Mall Gazette, 41 (6224). , (February 28), Wilde
Uncontrolled Keywords: Identity students; Nurses; Nursing; article; conflict; human; nursing education; nursing evaluation research; nursing methodology research; nursing staff; nursing student; organization; organization and management; psychological aspect; social behavior; Conflict (Psychology); Education, Nursing; Humans; Nursing Education Research; Nursing Staff, Hospital; Organizational Culture; Social Identification; Students, Nursing
Depositing User: National Forum
Date Deposited: 30 Nov 2015 13:59
Last Modified: 30 Nov 2015 13:59

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year