Teaching philosophy to engineering students

Heywood, J. and Grimson, W. and Korte, R. (2009) Teaching philosophy to engineering students. [Conference Proceedings]

Full text not available from this resource.
Official URL: http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?eid=2-s2.0...


The intention of this paper is to accompany the two special sessions on teaching philosophy in engineering courses as a vehicle for reflection on the subject matter of these sessions. In recent years there have been substantial international discussions on the subject of engineering and philosophy. The second of two international workshops on philosophy and engineering was held at the Royal Academy of Engineering in November 2008. Many of the outcomes of these deliberations have a bearing on the engineering curriculum and they coincide with a resurgent debate about content and method in the liberal education of engineers. At FIE 2007 and 2008 special sessions and a number of papers focused on engineering education and the more specific philosophy of education. These developments will be reviewed. One of the emerging issues that relate philosophy and the psychology of development has been the treatment of ethics within the context of moral development. Another emerging issue, the principle subject of this paper, is the idea that in addition to ethics philosophy should be taught to engineering students. But the proponents of this view do not, it seems, speak with one voice and this for the want of a more substantial and focused debate on the issue. The different views may be posed as questions thus: Should, philosophy be taught as a separate course or integrated into existing programmes, as for example design where there is already a relevant and high quality literature? If philosophy is taught as a separate course is its purpose to provide an understanding of the traditional disciplines of philosophy and the bearing they have on engineering, or is it to help students acquire a philosophical disposition (habit of mind)? If it is the latter how does that differ from the commonly held goal of higher education- the development of skill in reflective (critical) thinking? Or, is it about training students in the use of philosophical techniques in engineering? And in respect of the last question is that liberal education? Apart from some European studies of the attitudes of engineering teachers to the introduction of philosophy into engineering programmes and American work on moral development there has been little relevant research and development in these areas. The purpose of this paper is to review these recent discussions in the light of the questions posed above with the intention of outlining areas for research. ©2009 IEEE.

Item Type: Conference Proceedings
Additional Information: Conference code: 79825; Export Date: 23 February 2015; CODEN: PFECD; Correspondence Address: Heywood, J.; Trinity College DublinIreland; email: heywoodj@eircom.net; References: (2007) Philosophy in Engineering, , Christensen, S. H. et al (eds) Academica, Aarhus, Denmark; (2008) Workshop on Philosophy and Engineering, , WPE-2007. Abstracts. University of Delft; (2008) 2008 Workshop on Philosophy and Engineering, , WPE- Abstracts Royal Academy of Engineering, London; Can Philosophy of engineering education improve the practice of engineering education? (2007) Proceedings Frontiers in Education Conference (IEEE), , Special session TIf-1 to 2; Continuing the FIE 2007 Conversation on: Can philosophy of engineering education improve the practice of engineering education? (2008) Proceedings Frontiers in Education Conference (IEEE), , Special Session T1A-1 to 2; Heywood, J., Think...about how others think. Liberal education and engineering (2007) Proceedings Frontiers in Education Conference (IEEE), pp. 20-24. , T3C-; Christensen, S.H., Erno-Kjolhede, E., Implementing liberal education in engineering studies in Denmark (2009) Engineering in Context, , In Christensen, S. H. (ed) Académica, Aarhus, Denmark; Williams, R., Education for the profession formerly known as engineering (2003) The Chronicle of Higher Education, , Issue January 24th; Dias, P., The engineers identity crisis (2008) Homo Faber Versus Homo Sapiens, pp. 23/24. , See ref 1 (c); Davis, M., Thinking like an Engineer (1998) Studies in the Ethics of A Profession, , Oxford University Press; Bowen, W.R., (2009) An Aspirational Engineering Ethic, , Springer; Buber, M., (2004) Land Thou, , Continuum, London; MacIntyre, A., (1985) After Virtue, , 2nd edition; Seymour, E., Hewitt, N.M., Talking about leaving (1997) Why Undergraduates Leave the Sciences, , Westview Press, Boulder, CO; Leydens, J. A and J. C. Lucena (2009) Knowledge valuation in humanitarian engineering education in ref 1 (a)Schioffonati, V., (2008) From Philosophy of Science to Philosophy of Engineering, , See ref 1 (c) pp46/47; , pp. 10/11. , Blockley, D (2008) integrating hard and soft systems in ref 1(c)Grimson, W., The philosophical nature of engineering- A characterisation of engineering using the language and activities of philosophy (2007) Proceedings Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Education, , Paper AC 2007-1611; noteKeynote lecture by N. McCarthy (2007) in ref 1 (b)Price, M. J (2008) Descartes and locke at the drawing board: philosophies of engineering design in ref 1 (c) pp 27/28Parodi, O., (2008) Hydraulics Engineering Reflected in the Humanities, pp. 90/92. , See ref 1 (c) pp; Goldberg, D.E., (2008) What Engineers Don't Learn and Why They Don't Learn It: And How Philosophy Might Fe Able to Help, pp. 85/86. , See ref 1 (c) pp; See ref 2(b)Cowan, J., (2006) On Becoming An Innovative University Teacher, , Reflection in Action 2nd edition. SRHE/Open University Press, Maidenhead; Simons, P., (2008) Varieties of Parthood. Ontology Learns from Engineering, pp. 71/72. , See ref 1 (c); Rescher, N., (2001) Philosophical Reasoning: A Study in the Methodology of Philosophizing, , Blackwell, MA; Rescher, N., (2001) Philosophical Reasoning: A Study in the Methodology of Philosophizing; Searle, J.R., (1995) The Construction of Social Reality, , Free Press, New York; Elster, J., Explaining technical change (1983) A Case Study in the Philosophy of Science, , Cambridge University Press; Kohlberg, L., Essays in moral development Vol2 (1984) Psychology of Moral Development, , Harper and Row, New York; Harding, T.S., The psychology of the 'ought' (2008) Proceedings Frontiers in Education Conference (IEEE), , S4H- 19 to 24; Narvaez, D., Human flourishing and moral development. Cognitive and neurobiological perspectives in virtue development (2008) Handbook of Moral and Character Education, , L. P. Nucci and D. Narvaez (eds) Routledge, New York; Perry, W.G., (1970) Intellectual and Ethical Development in College Years, , A Scheme. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York
Uncontrolled Keywords: Engineering education; Ethics; Philosophical reasoning; Philosophy; Engineering course; Engineering curriculum; Engineering programmes; Engineering teachers; High quality; Higher education; International workshops; Liberal education; Moral development; Research and development; Royal Academy of Engineering; Subject matters; Teaching philosophy; Training students; Bearings (structural); Behavioral research; Curricula; Engineering; Ontology; Philosophical aspects; Students; Teaching; Technical presentations
Depositing User: National Forum
Date Deposited: 08 Dec 2015 21:25
Last Modified: 08 Dec 2015 21:25
URI: http://eprints.teachingandlearning.ie/id/eprint/2502

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year